Team play and collusion in poker clubs: how to spot and avoid it
Player collusion remains one of the main threats to fair play in club apps. We explain the schemes, the signs at the table, how apps fight them and what to do if you suspect team play.
Collusion, or team play, is when several players at one table act as a team against the others. They share information about their cards, squeeze opponents together with bets or pass chips to each other. In classic licensed rooms security teams with huge hand databases fight this. Club apps have protection too, but part of the responsibility falls on clubs, unions and players themselves.
The good news is that most collusion schemes leave traces. If you know what to look for, suspicious behaviour can be spotted within a few dozen hands. In this article we cover the main types of team play, signs at the table, a sample hand and what to do if you think you have been a victim.
Why collusion is possible in clubs
Club apps were built as a place to play with friends. So it is easy for people who know each other to sit at one table: just join one club and pick one table. Many play from phones, sitting next to each other or chatting in a messenger. On top of that, some club owners have little interest in strict checks if a team generates a lot of rake.
On the other hand, large apps and unions have powerful analysis tools: they see all players’ cards, compare IP addresses, devices and geolocation, and track stats for pairs of players. So systematic collusion is hard to hide for long, and the penalty usually includes a ban and confiscation of the balance.
Main types of collusion
Sharing card information
The most common scheme. Partners tell each other their cards by voice or in a messenger. Knowing two extra cards, a player estimates odds more precisely and folds and calls correctly more often. In one hand the edge is small, but over time it becomes a serious advantage.
Whipsaw
Two partners sit so that the victim is between them. When the victim enters the pot, one bets and the other raises, and a player with a good but not top hand has to either pay a huge amount or fold. The partners do not care which of them wins; the goal is to squeeze out the third.
Soft play
Partners never play seriously against each other: no bluffs, no value bets, checking to showdown. This is itself a rule violation, because every player at the table must play in their own interest. Soft play shows in how often two players reach showdown without any bets.
Chip dumping
One player deliberately loses chips to another. This is used to move money between accounts, launder bonuses or help a partner in a tournament. The sign of chip dumping is odd all-ins with very weak hands against the same opponent.
What a whipsaw looks like in practice
Look at the hand below. Two players who always sit together play a pot with the hero. The first opens, the second calls, the hero calls with suited AQ. On the flop the hero makes top pair, top kicker. The first partner bets and the second immediately makes a big raise. The hero has a good hand, but against a bet and a raise from two opponents it looks weak, and they fold. At showdown one partner had air and the other a draw. That is how a whipsaw works: the pot is won without a strong hand.
Whipsaw: two players squeeze out the hero with top pair
NL Hold’em · Cash · $0.10/$0.20
SB
SB · $19.90
BB
BB · $19.80
Player A
UTG · $20
Player B
HJ · $20
Hero
CO · $20
BTN
BTN · $20
Blinds are posted, cards are dealt
Hand history
Preflop
Player A (UTG) — raises to $0.60; Player B (HJ) — calls $0.60; Hero (CO) — calls $0.60; BTN (BTN) — folds; SB (SB) — folds; BB (BB) — folds
FlopQ♦ 9♣ 5♠
Player A (UTG) — bets $1; Player B (HJ) — raises to $3.50; Hero (CO) — folds; Player A (UTG) — folds
Player B (HJ) wins $4.10. Player B (HJ): uncalled bet of $2.50 returned
One such hand proves nothing: the players could have played it that way without colluding. Suspicion arises when such spots repeat: the partners never go against each other, yet regularly squeeze a third player together.
Signs of collusion at the table
Watch the behaviour of pairs of players, not individuals. Keep notes with hand numbers: within a week the picture becomes clearer. If you use a HUD where it is allowed, look at stats against a specific opponent: colluding partners’ numbers against each other differ sharply from their overall ones.
Behaviour | Normal | Suspicious |
|---|---|---|
Two regulars in a pot | Bet and bluff each other | Always check to showdown |
Raise and re-raise | Happens with strong hands | Regularly when a third player is in |
Table choice | Sit where the game is | Always together and side by side |
All-ins | With understandable ranges | With junk, favouring one of them |
Folds | Logical | Strong hands folded to a “friend’s” bet |
How apps fight collusion
Large apps analyse hands automatically. Algorithms look for pairs of accounts that sit together too often, rarely play against each other and beat third players more often than usual. IP addresses, devices and GPS coordinates on phones are checked. Some apps forbid players on the same network or with close geolocation from sitting at one table. More on protective measures in how apps fight fraud.
Unions and clubs add their own rules: they limit the number of tables, require identity confirmation and investigate complaints. Collusion does not pay for honest clubs: if recreational players feel the game is unfair, they leave and the rake disappears.
Collusion rarely hides in one hand. It shows in patterns: who sits with whom, who never bets against whom and who always beats third players.
What to do if you suspect collusion
Do not accuse players in the chat: it achieves nothing, and the suspects will simply change tables. Instead, collect hand numbers and send them to the club administration and app support. The more specific hands you attach, the better the chance that the check produces results. If the club ignores complaints and protects suspicious players, it is a reason to change clubs, as discussed in scam club signs.
How to reduce the risk
Play in large unions with an active security team.
Choose tables with recreational players rather than the same groups of regulars.
Do not sit between two players who always play together.
Leave the table if a pair of opponents behaves questionably.
Withdraw profits regularly and do not keep a large balance in a dubious club.
A separate threat to fair play is bots and real-time assistance. More in bots in mobile poker.
FAQ
Can I play at the same table as a friend?
Most apps do not forbid sitting at one table with someone you know, but they forbid sharing information and soft-playing each other. Some clubs ask players who know each other not to sit together to avoid suspicion.
Will I get my money back if collusion is proven?
Sometimes apps and unions distribute confiscated funds among victims, but this is not guaranteed. Most often the penalty is limited to banning the offenders.
Can a club take part in collusion?
Unfortunately, yes. That is why it is important to choose clubs with a good reputation and check agents, see how to choose a club.
Summary
Collusion in clubs takes the form of card sharing, whipsaws, soft play and chip dumping. It is revealed by patterns in the behaviour of pairs of players, not by single hands. Record suspicious hand numbers, report to the club and support, do not sit between suspicious players and choose large unions with active protection. That way you keep the risk of team play to a minimum.