All-in insurance in poker apps: is it worth buying
Many club apps offer the player who is ahead after an all-in the chance to buy insurance against the opponent catching up. It sounds tempting, but in the long run insurance almost always benefits the club, not the player. We look at how it works, how to price it, how it differs from run it twice and when it might still make sense.
Insurance is a feature that appeared in Asian club apps and spread quickly. When two players go all-in and the cards are turned up, the app counts how many outs the trailing player has and offers the leader insurance on the pot. The leader pays a premium, and if the opponent hits, receives a payout. If not, the premium is lost and the leader takes the pot.
At first glance it is a way to avoid painful bad beats. But the club sells the insurance, and the price includes a margin. That means each insurance purchase reduces your winnings on average. More on other table settings in club table settings.
How insurance works
Insurance is usually offered after an all-in on the flop or turn. The app shows the opponent’s outs, the cards that give them the win, and the payout ratio. You choose the amount to insure and pay a premium. The more outs the opponent has, the more expensive the insurance. Some clubs offer separate insurance for the turn and river after a flop all-in.
What the player sees
The insurance window usually shows the opponent’s outs, the payout ratio and an amount field. There are often quick buttons: insure what you put in, insure the whole pot or choose an amount manually. You get a few seconds to decide, and the app may automatically decline if you run out of time. This short timer is no accident: it nudges you towards an emotional decision, so it helps to decide in advance whether you buy insurance at all.
Differences between clubs
The club sets the insurance rules: some enable it at all tables, others only at Omaha or high-stakes tables, and some turn it off entirely. Ratios and the minimum number of outs required also differ. Sometimes the club caps the maximum amount. Before playing, check the table settings and ask your agent how payouts are calculated in the club.
Insurance in Omaha
In Omaha flop all-ins with many outs happen more often than in hold’em, so insurance is offered more often. With 12-15 outs it is expensive, and the club’s margin in money terms grows with the pot. So Omaha players who regularly buy insurance lose noticeable sums on it. More in best apps for Omaha.
Hand: a set against a flush draw
The hero on the button calls an open with pocket nines. On a 9-5-2 flop with two hearts the hero has a set, while the opponent with ace-queen of hearts has a flush draw. After raises the money goes in. This is a typical spot where the app offers insurance.
Set vs flush draw: all-in on the flop
NL Hold’em · Cash · $0.10/$0.20
SB
SB · $19.90
BB
BB · $19.80
UTG
UTG · $20
HJ
HJ · $20
CO
CO · $20
Hero
BTN · $20
Blinds are posted, cards are dealt
Hand history
Preflop
UTG (UTG) — folds; HJ (HJ) — folds; CO (CO) — raises to $0.50; Hero (BTN) — calls $0.50; SB (SB) — folds; BB (BB) — folds
Flop9♥ 5♥ 2♣
CO (CO) — bets $0.60; Hero (BTN) — raises to $1.80; CO (CO) — raises to $19.50, all-in; Hero (BTN) — calls $17.70, all-in
Turn3♠
RiverK♦
Hero (BTN) wins $40.30 (Three of a kind)
On the flop the opponent has nine flush outs. With two cards to come their chance is about 35% and the hero’s about 65%. Here the turn and river bricked and the hero took the pot. If the hero had bought insurance, the premium would have been lost and the pot would be the same.
How to price it
A fair insurance price matches the probability that the opponent catches up. Say on the turn the opponent has 9 outs among 44 unseen cards, about 20%. The fair payout would then be about 4 to 1: insuring 40 dollars, you pay about 10. The club usually offers a lower ratio, such as 3.5 to 1 or less. The difference is the club’s margin, which you pay with every purchase.
Outs on the river | Probability | Fair payout | Often in clubs |
|---|---|---|---|
4 | about 9% | about 10:1 | below 9:1 |
8 | about 18% | about 4.5:1 | about 4:1 |
9 | about 20% | about 4:1 | about 3.5:1 |
12 | about 27% | about 2.7:1 | about 2.3:1 |
Exact ratios depend on the club and app, but the principle is the same: insurance is sold above the fair price. In the long run this is a direct loss, like extra rake. More on probabilities in the glossary: outs, equity.
Insurance or run it twice
Run it twice means the remaining cards are dealt twice and the pot is split by the two results. It also reduces swings but costs nothing: your expected value does not change. If a table offers run it twice, it is almost always a better choice than insurance. More on other ways to reduce risk in bankroll management in clubs.
When insurance may make sense
Insurance can be justified when the pot is huge relative to your bankroll and losing would force you to move down or stop playing. In that case you pay not for expectation but to reduce the risk of ruin. But it is better not to get into such situations: if one pot can badly hurt your bankroll, you are playing too high.
Another option is partial insurance: insuring only what you put in rather than the whole pot. It is cheaper and still reduces swings. But you still pay the club’s margin.
The psychology of insurance
Clubs offer insurance because it is profitable for them and pleasant for players. After a bad beat you especially want to buy it, and that is an emotional decision. Remember: losing with a strong hand is variance, not a mistake. If you tend to tilt after such hands, work on discipline rather than paying for insurance regularly. More in tilt and discipline.
Insurance is a product the club sells. And products are sold when they benefit the seller.
FAQ
Can you win with insurance?
In a single hand yes, if the opponent catches up. But in the long run, at a price above fair, you lose.
Do I have to buy insurance?
No. It is optional and you can always decline.
Does insurance count towards rakeback?
Usually not. Ask your agent: in some clubs the insurance margin is separate from rake.
Summary
All-in insurance protects against bad beats but is sold above the fair price, so in the long run it benefits the club. If run it twice is available, use it: it is free. Buying insurance makes sense only in rare cases when the pot is too big for your bankroll, and it is better to choose stakes where such situations do not arise.